top of page

Top 5 Mistakes Companies Make When Selecting an HRIS Vendor

Choosing the right Human Resources Information System vendor is a critical decision that impacts your organization’s efficiency, compliance, and employee experience. However, many companies make the same common mistakes during the selection process, leading to frustration, wasted resources, and underperforming systems.


In this blog, we’ll explore the top five mistakes organizations make when selecting an HRIS vendor, provide real-world examples, and offer actionable solutions for how to avoid these issues.


Mistake 1: Focusing Solely on Cost


The Problem: Many companies prioritize finding the cheapest option without considering the system’s functionality, scalability, or total cost of ownership (TCO). A low-cost solution might save money upfront but can lead to higher expenses over time due to limited features, expensive upgrades, or lack of support.


Example: A mid-sized company selects a budget HRIS with minimal payroll integration capabilities. After implementation, they incur significant costs hiring external consultants to build custom integrations.


Solution:

  • Evaluate the TCO, including implementation, training, support, and potential future upgrades.

  • Create a feature list based on organizational needs and compare vendors’ offerings against this list.

  • Balance cost considerations with long-term value.


Mistake 2: Overlooking Scalability and Flexibility


The Problem: Companies often choose a system that meets their current needs but doesn’t accommodate growth or adapt to changing business requirements. This short-term thinking can lead to system replacements sooner than expected.


Example: A fast-growing startup selects an HRIS designed for small businesses. Within two years, the company expands to multiple locations, and the system can’t handle multi-state payroll or compliance requirements.


Solution:

  • Choose a system that can scale with your organization’s growth and evolving needs.

  • Ask vendors about system limitations and plans for future enhancements.

  • Include stakeholders from various departments to ensure the system supports cross-functional requirements.


Mistake 3: Neglecting User Experience (UX)


The Problem: Companies often focus on the HRIS’s backend functionality while neglecting its usability for HR teams, managers, and employees. A complex or unintuitive system can lead to low adoption rates and inefficiencies.


Example: An enterprise implements an HRIS with robust analytics but receives constant complaints from employees about the cumbersome time-tracking interface, leading to manual workarounds.


Solution:

  • Request a live demo and involve end users in evaluating the system’s interface.

  • Prioritize systems with simple navigation, self-service capabilities, and mobile access.

  • Pilot the system with a small group to gather feedback before full implementation.


Mistake 4: Ignoring Vendor Support and Service


The Problem: Companies often underestimate the importance of post-implementation support. Without reliable vendor support, even minor issues can escalate, causing delays and dissatisfaction.


Example: A company discovers that their vendor’s support is limited to email during business hours, leaving critical issues unresolved for days.


Solution:

  • Review the vendor’s support offerings, including response times, service hours, and escalation protocols.

  • Speak with existing customers to assess the quality of the vendor’s support.

  • Negotiate SLAs (Service Level Agreements) to ensure adequate support levels.


Mistake 5: Rushing the Decision-Making Process


The Problem: Tight deadlines or pressure to modernize HR operations can lead to hasty decisions without proper due diligence. This often results in choosing a system that doesn’t fully align with organizational needs.


Example: A company skips a comprehensive RFP process and selects a vendor based on a single demo, only to find that the system lacks essential features like compliance tracking.


Solution:

  • Develop a detailed RFP that outlines your organization’s specific needs, goals, and priorities.

  • Schedule multiple demos and involve cross-functional stakeholders in the evaluation process.

  • Allow ample time for reviewing contracts, references, and integration capabilities.


Selecting the right HRIS vendor requires careful planning, thorough evaluation, and a focus on long-term needs. By avoiding these common mistakes, your organization can choose a system that supports your HR goals, scales with your business, and delivers measurable value.


If you need expert guidance in selecting and implementing an HRIS, ROCKCREST’s consulting team is here to help. We specialize in helping companies navigate the complexities of HR technology to make informed, strategic decisions. Contact us today to learn how we can support your journey to HRIS success.


Our Services:
Practice Areas:

CONTACT

​Fill out the form to schedule a free consultation. Our representatives are available to discuss your objectives, our consulting solutions and how we can bring value to your organization.

bottom of page